Sherburne NY Real Estate & Homes for Sale

Welcome to small-town living at its best! This charming farmhouse-style home in the heart of Earlville offers space, character, and the relaxing village lifestyle buyers are looking for. Enjoy morning coffee or evening sunsets from the classic wraparound farmhouse porch, the perfect place to take in the peaceful small-town atmosphere and friendly neighborhood feel. Inside, the home features 5 spacious bedrooms with potential for a 6th, providing incredible flexibility for an additional bedroom. This space is also ideal for extra storage, a home office, or even a future full bathroom, offering room to expand and customize. Step outside to enjoy the private backyard with beautiful established gardens, creating a peaceful retreat right at home. The property backs directly to the baseball field, giving you open views and that nostalgic village backdrop that truly captures the spirit of community living. Car enthusiasts, hobbyists, and anyone needing extra space will appreciate the detached 2.5-car garage with plenty of room for storage and workspace. There's also a huge shed perfect for storing lawn equipment, toys, or creating your own she-shed or man cave. Located on a street with sidewalks and a true village feel, and within the Sherburne-Earlville School District, this property blends charm, space, and potential in a setting that embodies relaxed small-town living. A rare opportunity to own a classic farmhouse with room to grow in the Village of Earlville - schedule your showing today!

Discover the historic charm and modern convenience of this property within the Village of Sherburne creating a remarkable 4-acre compound: (1) Stunning 4,546+/- SF main residence, built by Clarence Gaines has 6 BR, 3 full, 2 half baths, great living spaces, lots of storage, 2 heated garage bays under and a new oversized 2 bay, detached garage. It has been meticulously updated. (2) Separate 1,260 sf ranch residence built in 2018 has 2 BR, 2 full baths, great room and laundry w 3 bay, attached garage, (3) For the equestrian/animal enthusiast, a two-stall horse barn, hay shed, and corral. The main house features a new kitchen, beautiful door and window moldings, hardwood floors and a unique octagon dining room. The entire property is served by economical Sherburne municipal electric, water & sewer. A geothermal heating and cooling system will keep you comfortable. Main house has new combination propane boiler/hot water heater and new geothermal heat pump in 2024. Sherburne is home to the Rogers Environmental Center, Gaines Memorial Park with its bandstand, Rexford Falls, Paddleford Park and the Town Public Library. Note: Antique gas pump next to the ranch house garage is excluded. School Tax is $5265 with Star exemption. See improvements list for additional information. Owner occupied. 24 hours notice, please.

Classic folk/cottage style 3 bed 2 bath house with charming traditional details. Steep front gable with decorative trim. Just under 3 ACRE lot in the village of Earlville. Newer oversized 2 car garage with rear insulated workshop room with upgraded electric ample for running machinery and a woodstove. Garage also has back garage door for efficiency out to the back acerage and deck. Enjoy leisure time on the covered porches. Eat-in country kitchen with formal dining room. First floor laundry and full bath, plus first floor main bedroom with full bath and closet. 2 Bedrooms upstairs, or 1 bedroom with other room for storage or office. Large living room with glass door to the back deck and pellet stove! Mostly level and rolling back yard where you can enjoy living in the village as well as having scenic land for recreation, gardening and space! Partially open and some wooded areas. Attic area has potential for more living space. 11 year old Gas furnace. Storybook inspired living with this village farmhouse and classic Americana look. Municpal Electric. Home available for closing/occupancy as of July 1 2026. 2.5 acres in the back is a separate tax parcel various potential!